Baby Shower Cakes

Cake Pops


What Our Customers Say

"Huge shout out to Tammy and Half baked!!!! They did an awesome job with the dessert tray for my grandfather's memorial service!! They were even kind enough to add one of my grandfathers favorite treats of buckeyes when we asked. For sure going to them for future events!" -Drew Harting

testimonial trolls cake

"Hi my name is Ronisha. I ordered a cake from you guys for my daughter 2nd birthday party and you guys did GREAT. YOU NAILED THE CAKE!!!!!!!!! Great art work and great flavor to the cake. BEST lemon cake I've ever had. The guest at the party along with my 2 year old loved it.  I will be ordering from you guys again in the future. I'm VERY please with your work.  AWESOME JOB!!!!!!!!! "

"Great experience! Friendly and informative people! Went to Sweet Melissa's first but the owner, who was present didn't even have time to help me, in fact wouldn't talk to me! Tammy at Half Baked was wonderful and very personable! Austin was great too! Highly recommend this place!"

"All I can say YUMMY!! They are very moist and fresh!!"

"I order all my cakes, cupcakes, and sweet treats from Half Baked. The cakes are very moist and flavorful. The cupcakes are to die for ! My son who has many food allergies is able to enjoy a vegan cupcake too. The gluten free is just as good ! They make healthy food taste yummy ! A must try!!"

Cake Top  

"After one year in my freezer, and wrapped perfectly, we never peaked until today; we were ne ver ever expecting this cake to look this beautiful when we opened it ! Most bakeries would have thrown two slices in there, and called it a day, but Half Baked, took the time to prepare a gorgeous ivory cake. Anyone planning a wedding; Half Baked in Middletown is definitely worth it, and their prices, are phenomenal. They can't be beat. Thank you for making our wedding perfect and our first year anniversary, that much better!!" -Xoxoxoxoxoo Danielle and Pete Franko


"Hi Tammy. Thank you and your staff for the delicious cupcakes and cookie tray on Saturday.  They were a big hit and very few left which I divided with my sisters.  The wedding at the Anchorage was absolutely beautiful and a fun time for all.  I'm so thankful my daughter Katie was familiar with your bakery and by sheer chance The Anchorage.  Thank you for your concern during that initial shock of the venue closing.  Things worked out for the best!  Warm regards" -Peggy Fay